Resources: Blog

What does your Enterprise Agreement really say?

Blog
|

Employers must be careful when drafting and negotiating Enterprise Agreements

On 8 October 2015 Justices Jessup, Bromberg and White of the Federal Court of Australia handed down separate judgments relating to the La Trobe University Enterprise Agreement. This decision may now see employers paying closer attention to what is contained within their policies and enterprise agreements.

On 8 October 2015 Justices Jessup, Bromberg and White of the Federal Court of Australia (Court) handed down separate judgments relating to the La Trobe University (University) Enterprise Agreement. This decision may now see employers paying closer attention to what is contained within their policies and enterprise agreements.

In October 2014 the University announced it was planning to impose proposed restructuring which would result in 280 employees having their employment terminated by way of redundancy.

The National Tertiary Education Union (the Union), relying on section 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the Act) (the section provides that a person must not contravene a term of an Enterprise Agreement) alleged that the University was not meeting all its obligations under the Enterprise Agreement with respect to redundancy.

The Enterprise Agreement specifically provided that:

The University is committed to job security. Wherever possible redundancies are to be avoided and compulsory retrenchment used as a last resort. The University reserves the right to use the agreed redundancy procedures and provisions set out in this Agreement when all reasonable attempts to mitigate against such action and to avoid job loss have been unsuccessful.

The University submitted that the above clause amounted to “no more than a series of aspirational or hortatory statements” and despite there being options to mitigate job losses within the University that did not mean that the University could not make compulsory retrenchments.

Justice Bromberg commented that whilst the Enterprise Agreement permits for the University to have compulsory retrenchments the main aim of the clause was “concerned with both maintaining the overall numbers of positions and maintaining the employments of La Trobe employees.” Further, Justice White observed that the wording of the clause did not specify what the University was required to do in order to discharge its obligation that it had mitigated against the possibility of termination of an employee’s employment as a result of job loss.

Therefore, it was found that the Enterprise Agreement obligated the University to exhaust all options and attempts to mitigate job loss prior to utilising compulsory retrenchment.

Employers must be careful when drafting and negotiating Enterprise Agreements. This seems obvious, but it is important for employers to fully understand what the clauses in an Enterprise Agreement mean in a practical and legal sense.

Every time an Enterprise Agreement is up for re-negotiation a thorough review should be undertaken to ensure that the employer is still comfortable with the specific wording of commitments given in the document. Some Enterprise Agreements still contain historical terms that were first included in Agreements in the 1980s or 1990s and make no sense at all in today’s workplace relations regime.

Sweeping generalisations and “feel good” statements such as the terms considered in this case should be avoided – for exactly the reasons set out in this case.

An Enterprise Agreement is ultimately an industrial instrument and should be drafted with a care for clarity in its terms.

 

Information provided in this blog is not legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Workplace Law does not accept liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on the content of this blog, or from links on this website to any external website. Where applicable, liability is limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

 

Similar articles

Server dismissed for inappropriate conduct towards co-workers

Out of service

Dismissing an employee for inappropriate conduct can be a challenging process, particularly when the employee does not accept that their conduct was inappropriate.

Read more...

The importance of correctly characterising employee conduct

In the driver’s sheet

Employers regularly have to deal with issues relating to employee behaviour, work performance and misconduct.

Read more...

Social media, sporting clubs and athletes

Doing It For The 'Gram

Since it arrived in Australia, Uber has been under fire for its disruption of the transport industry and its complicated relationship with its drivers.

Read more...

Salary reduction brought employee under high income threshold

Below not above

The COVID-19 (coronavirus) pandemic has significantly impacted the financial stability of many businesses. Employers have had to make difficult decisions and implement different measures to ensure the ongoing viability of their businesses. Some of these measures have included asking employees to agree to temporary reductions in their hours of work or to a reduction in their remuneration.

Read more...

Company vicariously liable for injury resulting from skylarking supervisor

All in good fun

Enjoying the company of your colleagues is something most people hope to find in the workplace. It can make work much more enjoyable and lead to lasting friendships. However, fun in the workplace can cross a line when it takes the form of dangerous skylarking or roughhousing.

Read more...

Managing employee conduct and behaviour in the workplace

Draw the line

Managing employee conduct and behaviour can be a challenge. The question of what is appropriate and what is not appropriate in the workplace will depend on a variety of factors, including the industry in which the employees work, the overall culture of the workplace and community standards at any given time.

Read more...

Let's talk

please contact our directors to discuss how ouR expertise can help your business.

We're here to help

Contact Us
Let Workplace Law become your partner in Workplace Relations.

Signup to receive the latest industry updates with commentary from the Workplace Law team direct to you inbox.