Resources: Blog

Employee dismissed for offensive remarks in the workplace

Blog
|

What did you say?

It goes without saying that employees should treat each other with respect and courtesy in the workplace. In a recent decision, the FWC was tasked with considering a claim from a dismissed employee who alleged that remarks he made in the workplace were not offensive and did not justify his dismissal.

It goes without saying that employees should treat each other with respect and courtesy in the workplace.

In a recent decision, the Fair Work Commission (FWC) was tasked with considering a claim from a dismissed employee who alleged that remarks he made in the workplace were not offensive and did not justify his dismissal - Chileshe v EnergyAustralia Pty Ltd [2019] FWC 7622.

The employee in this case was a customer save consultant and had been working for his employer for about two years. In 2018, as part of his employment, the employee attended a training course with his colleagues about identifying customer concerns over telephone. The training required the attendees to diagnose a customer’s issues as though they were a doctor.

In the course of the exercise, the employee said to the trainer “Ask these guys”, meaning the three colleagues sitting next to him who he believed to be Indian. The trainer asked, “Why these guys?” and the employee responded, “They’re Indian, and all Indians are doctors.”

One of the colleagues said that they were not Indian to which the employee replied, “You can be a taxi driver then.”

After the training session, an attendee complained to the employer about the comments. An investigation was conducted and the employee was issued with a first and final warning stating that the employee’s remarks breached the employer’s code of conduct, values and diversity policy.

Then, in December 2018, the employee made an unsolicited comment to a colleague in words to the effect of, “People like you can’t get pregnant.” The comment implied that, due to the individual’s sexual orientation, she would not be able to have children. The colleague gave evidence that she was upset by the comment and felt it was dehumanising.

Finally, in March 2019, the employee attended a team huddle where colleagues were asked to share something personal about themselves. Before one of the employee’s colleagues (who was of Indian decent) could speak, the employee said, “What, don’t tell us you’re related to Deepak Chopra.” The colleague said, “That’s racist, Richard”, and the employee responded, “Oh, sorry.”

Another colleague who was present at the huddle made a complaint about the employee’s comments.

An investigation was conducted by the employer into the two incidents and the employee was invited to respond to the allegations against him. Ultimately, the investigation concluded that the employee had made the comments as alleged and they were in breach of the employer’s code of conduct and diversity policy.

The employee was invited to show cause as to why his employment should not be terminated. The employee attempted to argue that the comment about his colleague being able to get pregnant was in response to her emotional state (having recently broken up with her girlfriend) and was not in reference to her sexuality. In respect to the comment in the huddle, the employee claimed that his colleague was not offended and his comment was not offensive.

The employer ultimately decided to dismiss the employee on the basis that he had received an earlier first and final warning for the same conduct and his later comments amounted to further breaches of the code of conduct and diversity policy.

Before the FWC, the employee attempted to argue that his comments were not offensive because his colleagues did not, or should not, have taken offence. Specifically, the employee claimed that his colleague in the huddle did not take offence and he had a joking relationship with his female colleague and they could say anything to each other. The colleague gave evidence that their relationship was non-existent and his comments were about her sexuality, not about her emotional state.

The FWC considered the comments objectively, noting that the whether or not the employee’s colleagues were offended would not be determinative of whether or not his statements breached the employer’s code of conduct and diversity policy.

The FWC held that the employee’s comments were offensive and discriminatory, and involved stereotyping on the basis of race. For this reason, the FWC was satisfied that the employee breached the employer’s code of conduct and diversity policy, which amounted to a valid reason for his dismissal.

The employee’s unfair dismissal application was dismissed.

Lessons for employers

Although it may seem like something you should not have to spell out for employees, employers should always make clear to employees that they expect them to treat each other with respect and courtesy and avoid remarks that are potentially offensive or discriminatory.

One method for setting expectations is to develop a code of conduct, clearly stating the behavioural expectations on employees and the consequences for failing to meet those expectations.

When incidents of unacceptable behaviour do occur, employers should act swiftly but fairly. Allowing an unacceptable pattern of behaviour to develop and continue can have a detrimental impact on the mental health of employees and can expose an employer to a range of liabilities for failing to provide a safe workplace.

 

Information provided in this blog is not legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Workplace Law does not accept liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on the content of this blog, or from links on this website to any external website. Where applicable, liability is limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

Similar articles

FWC upholds dismissal of an employee who repeatedly and deliberately accessed customer’s confidential information without authorisation

Celebrity search

During the course of their employment, employees may have access to confidential information which belongs to their employer. This information may be in the form of personal information provided by customers and is therefore sensitive in nature.

Read more...

Full Bench quashes order to reinstate labour hire employee to host employer

Host with the most

In the unfair dismissal jurisdiction, where it is found by the Fair Work Commission (FWC) that an employee has been unfairly dismissed, the primary remedy under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) is for the employee to be reinstated to the position they held immediately prior to their dismissal or another position on no less favourable terms.

Read more...

Court finds rescinded job offer was not age discrimination

The rooster and the sunrise

Discrimination in the workplace is unlawful under a number of Australian laws, including state and federal anti-discrimination legislation (such as the Age Discrimination Act 2004 (Cth)) as well as the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act).

Read more...

Court fines PCBU $60,000 for failing to re-assess the risks associated with changing site conditions

Set and forget

Persons conducting a business or undertaking (PCBUs) have a positive obligation to ensure, so far as reasonably practicable, the health and safety of workers and others.

Read more...

Employee fails in bid to have safety-related dismissal found to be unfair

Garbage in, garbage out

A dismissed employee can lodge an unfair dismissal claim alleging that their dismissal was “harsh, unjust or unreasonable”. Employees will often claim that the dismissal was all three: harsh, unjust and unreasonable.

Read more...

Fair Work Commission finds employer’s failure to comply with its consultation obligations rendered an employee’s dismissal to be unfair

Pick up the phone

The COVID-19 pandemic has had an unprecedented effect on Australian businesses. Employers have had to, with little notice, adapt to these changing circumstances to try and minimise the adverse impact of lockdowns on the business and its employees.

Read more...

Let's talk

please contact our directors to discuss how ouR expertise can help your business.

We're here to help

Contact Us
Let Workplace Law become your partner in Workplace Relations.

Signup to receive the latest industry updates with commentary from the Workplace Law team direct to you inbox.