Resources: Blogs

Where employee misbehaviour or misconduct occurs, it should be addressed immediately in the workplace, if it is not, the employer is seen to have “lost” or waived the opportunity to take corrective disciplinary action.

Blogs
|

FOMODA: Fear of Missing Out on Disciplinary Action

The Fair Work Commission has often held that a dismissal will be found to be harsh, unjust or unreasonable when one of the reasons for the termination of employment included an event which occurred earlier and which was not addressed at the time. This is encapsulated in the concept of “use it or lose it”.

The Fair Work Commission (the Commission) has often held that a dismissal will be found to be harsh, unjust or unreasonable when one of the reasons for the termination of employment included an event which occurred earlier and which was not addressed at the time. This is encapsulated in the concept of “use it or lose it”.

Where employee misbehaviour or misconduct occurs, it should be addressed immediately in the workplace, if it is not, the employer is seen to have “lost” or waived the opportunity to take corrective disciplinary action.

The Commission has used the same approach when considering whether an employer’s disciplinary action was bullying or reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable manner.

In Ms Belinda Brown v Park Beach Bowling Club Limited; Ms Kelly Walcot and Mr Grant Walden [2017] FWC 896, the employee claimed that she was bullied by the Park Beach Bowling Club (the Club) management. She claimed that she was treated unfairly and subjected to inconsistent disciplinary action.

The employee was employed as a casual food and bar attendant by the Club and made a number of allegations that she was bullied. In particular, the employee alleged that she was subjected to unreasonable actions by the Club when it investigated complaints from two employees against her. One complaint concerned an allegation that in October 2015 Ms Brown commented “Maybe I have to put on 80 kg before I can get recognised for an award” about another employee who received a recognition award from the Club.

The Club first received this complaint in October 2015 and it was investigated over the course of November 2015. The employee was advised a number of times between February and May 2016 that the investigation did not find that she made the comment, so no action would be taken against her and that the matter was closed. Despite advising the employee of this, in October 2016, the Club issued the employee with a warning letter in relation to making inappropriate and insulting comments toward the other employee.

The Commission was critical of the Club’s actions in issuing a warning letter to the employee having earlier told her that no further action would be taken. The Commission held that the Club’s decision to issue the employee with a warning letter relating to an incident which occurred nearly twelve months earlier was unreasonable and was not reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable manner.

Despite this finding in relation to the warning letter, the Commission dismissed the employee’s other allegations of unreasonable behaviour by the Club and found that the Club acted reasonably toward the employee. Accordingly, there was no repeated unreasonable behaviour toward the employee. The Commission found that the employee had not been bullied at work and dismissed the application.

Employee misbehaviour should be addressed at first instance and should not be left to be addressed at a later time. Certainly a disciplinary process would be very likely to be considered unreasonable if an employer firstly advised an employee that no disciplinary action will be taken only to (much) later, with the “fear of missing out on taking disciplinary action”, issue the employee with a warning.

 

Similar articles

Prevention is better than a cure

Planning end of year work celebrations

As the end of another year approaches, employers are understandingly planning a well-earned opportunity for employees to celebrate the year that has been.

Read more...

Fair Work Commission upholds dismissal of an employee who misused a company coffee account

Caffeine Hit

Financial misconduct committed by an employee can fundamentally damage the trust and confidence in an employment relationship. Unfortunately, financial misconduct is a common issue for Australian businesses and if it is not dealt with promptly and effectively, there is an opportunity for further misadventure.

Read more...

FWC upholds dismissal of an employee who repeatedly and deliberately accessed customer’s confidential information without authorisation

Celebrity search

During the course of their employment, employees may have access to confidential information which belongs to their employer. This information may be in the form of personal information provided by customers and is therefore sensitive in nature.

Read more...

Employer successfully rebuts presumption in adverse action claim

Return to sender

An employer has successfully defended an adverse action claim brought by a former employee as the court was satisfied that the employee was not dismissed for a prohibited reason.

Read more...

Commission finds inappropriate social media use formed valid reason for dismissal

Message delivered

A recent decision of the Fair Work Commission has confirmed that an employee’s inappropriate use of social media group chats may form a valid reason for dismissal, particularly when matters relating to work are discussed.

Read more...

Commission confirms inappropriate touching constituted sexual harassment warranting summary dismissal

‘Scuse you

Sexual harassment in the workplace has been the subject of significant reform over the past few years, with an even greater onus on employers now to take proactive measures to minimise or eliminate the risk of sexual harassment in connection with work.

Read more...

Let's talk

please contact our directors to discuss how ouR expertise can help your business.

We're here to help

Contact Us
Let Workplace Law become your partner in Workplace Relations.

Sign up to receive the latest industry updates with commentary from the Workplace Law team direct to your inbox.