Resources: Blogs

Let me restart

Blogs
|

Anti-bullying orders issued to employer and employee to reset the employment relationship

The anti-bullying jurisdiction of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) gives the Fair Work Commission (FWC) a broad power to make any order it considers appropriate to prevent a worker from being bullied at work (except an order which requires monetary payment).

The anti-bullying jurisdiction of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) gives the Fair Work Commission (FWC) a broad power to make any order it considers appropriate to prevent a worker from being bullied at work (except an order which requires monetary payment).

In Burbeck v Alice Springs Town Council; Davison; Price; Fisher [2017] FWC 4988, the FWC issued orders against the Applicant and her employer after it found that the Applicant’s own conduct and behaviour was at times unreasonable and had a contributory effect to the unreasonable conduct and behaviour of the employer and its employees.

The Applicant was employed as a Children’s and Youth Services Officer at Alice Springs Public Library. She made an application for stop-bullying orders alleging that she was bullied by her supervisor, the library manager and director.

The Applicant relied upon six specific matters which she alleged amounted to bullying conduct by the employer and its employees. The Applicant’s complaints mainly concerned the issuing of letters, performance counselling, complaints made but not investigated and the revocation of her approved annual leave.

The FWC considered the allegations and the surrounding circumstances. It determined that four of the six allegations about the employer’s conduct were not reasonable management action conducted in a reasonable manner by the employer and accordingly concluded that the behaviour constituted bullying.

In considering the possible orders which could be made, the FWC commented that in many cases involving bullying allegations which come before it, there are aspects of poor behaviour on both or many sides.

In this case, the Applicant’s behaviour was also considered to be unreasonable. The FWC accepted that, following the Applicant’s return from long service leave, she resented her new supervisor and had a perception that she was more qualified than her supervisor. The FWC noted that the Applicant wanted to be “impervious” to critiques of her performance and her criticism of the employer’s decision to undertake performance counselling was a “diversionary tactic”. In addition, the FWC held that the Applicant needed to improve her interpersonal skills and there was a pattern of “generally pushing back at all opportunities”.

The FWC considered it was appropriate to make orders against both the Applicant and her employer. These orders included setting aside matters relating to the allegation letters, requiring that the Applicant participate in performance counselling and comply with the employer’s Code of Conduct. The orders also required the Respondent to arrange for anti-bullying and communication training in the library.

Lessons for employers

In this matter, the FWC made orders for the purpose of resetting the employment relationship between the Applicant and the employer to allow them to move forward on an even basis.

As noted above, the FWC can make any stop-bullying orders it considers to be appropriate, such as requiring the employer to update an anti-bullying policy or undertake training and restraining a party from certain conduct.

The ultimate goal for stop-bullying orders is to stop and prevent the behaviour and encourage good working relationships.

 

Information provided in this blog is not legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Workplace Law does not accept liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on the content of this blog, or from links on this website to any external website. Where applicable, liability is limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

 

Similar articles

Employer found liable for workers compensation despite worker’s unreasonable perceptions

Fact or fiction

A recent decision of the New South Wales Personal Injury Commission serves as a reminder of the differing standards of proof when determining liability for claims of bullying and/or harassment under workers compensation laws and the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

Read more...

Prevention is better than a cure

Planning end of year work celebrations

As the end of another year approaches, employers are understandingly planning a well-earned opportunity for employees to celebrate the year that has been.

Read more...

Bullying allegations used as a tactic to direct attention away from an employee’s misconduct

Bullying tactics

It is not uncommon for employees to raise allegations against Employers in order to divert attention away from, or attempt to excuse their own misconduct.

Read more...

Commission confirms inappropriate touching constituted sexual harassment warranting summary dismissal

‘Scuse you

Sexual harassment in the workplace has been the subject of significant reform over the past few years, with an even greater onus on employers now to take proactive measures to minimise or eliminate the risk of sexual harassment in connection with work.

Read more...

Employers delay sinks bid for injunctive relief

Speak now

When seeking to enforce a restraint, it is important that employers seek to enforce the restraint in a timely manner to prevent future or an ongoing breach. Any delay will be considered by the courts when assessing whether it is reasonable to enforce the restraint.

Read more...

Two-year post-employment restraint on hairdresser found to be unreasonable

Splitting hairs

When it comes to drafting post-employment restraints in employment contracts, it is important for employers to consider the purpose of the restraint and whether or not the restraint reasonably serves that purpose.

Read more...

Let's talk

please contact our directors to discuss how ouR expertise can help your business.

We're here to help

Contact Us
Let Workplace Law become your partner in Workplace Relations.

Sign up to receive the latest industry updates with commentary from the Workplace Law team direct to your inbox.