Resources: Blog

$275,000 damages bill flows from shallow puddle injury

Blog
|

Puddle trouble

During the recruitment process, employers want to present their best side to prospective employees in order to entice top talent to join them. Employers can potentially expose themselves to litigation for representations made or made on their behalf that are misleading and deceptive and later relied upon by prospective employees in the recruitment process.

In a recent decision of the Victorian County Court, a university has been ordered to pay $275,000 in damages to a security control room operator who worked on the university campus (Savage v Monash University and Programmed Maintenance Services Ltd [2017] VCC 1774).

The control room operator was walking from her car to the security control room in steel capped boots when she stepped through a puddle onto the uneven surface below and injured her ankle. The ankle injury required arthroscopic surgery, after which the control room operator developed a chronic pain condition and depression, and became incapacitated for work.

The location where the injury occurred was a wide section of a median strip separating two roads on the university’s campus. The section of the median strip was designated for pedestrians crossing the roads and was surfaced with a crushed granite/gravel material. On the particular day in question, rain water had pooled in sections of the median strip surface, creating puddles. The depth of those puddles was not immediately ascertainable nor was the state of the surface at the bottom of the puddles.

The control room operator stepped in a puddle, that was said to be two centimetres deep at the most, and rolled her ankle.

The Court found that the University had a responsibility to the 5000 plus students, staff and other visitors who used the crossing in question every day. The university had failed to ensure that the surface of the median strip crossing was properly maintained given its susceptibility to degradation and previous, though undocumented, instances of trips and falls.

The potential seriousness of any injury resulting from the uneven surface and the University’s failure to either fill-in ditches in the uneven surface, or replace the uneven surface with a permanent all-weather surface (like concrete) lead to a finding that its duty of care to those using the crossing had not been discharged.

The Court found the university liable for the control room operator’s injury and ordered that she be paid $275,000 in damages.

 

Lessons

Under common law and statute, employers have a responsibility to make sure that the working environment and any premises they maintain are safe for employees, clients and any other visitors.

Employers must take all reasonable steps necessary to ensure that even the smallest hazards are identified and addressed as and when they are identified (ideally through regular risk and safety audits).

In this case, the hazard of small puddles concealing an uneven surface from pedestrians was not obvious when the median strip crossing was dry. It was not until rain water pooled and created puddles that an obvious hazard developed.

Learning from this example, employers should consider how weather conditions or other environmental changes may impact on their premises or workplace and how such changes could result in previously minor hazards becoming significant hazards.

 

Information provided in this blog is not legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Workplace Law does not accept liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on the content of this blog, or from links on this website to any external website. Where applicable, liability is limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

 

Similar articles

Company vicariously liable for injury resulting from skylarking supervisor

All in good fun

Enjoying the company of your colleagues is something most people hope to find in the workplace. It can make work much more enjoyable and lead to lasting friendships. However, fun in the workplace can cross a line when it takes the form of dangerous skylarking or roughhousing.

Read more...

Brisbane company first to be convicted of industrial manslaughter

Brisbane company first to be convicted of industrial manslaughter

Workplace fatalities are tragic and devastating events. In order to reflect the seriousness of these incidents, some jurisdictions across Australia have amended their work health and safety laws to establish the offence of industrial manslaughter, where the negligent conduct by a person conducting a business or undertaking or officers causes the death of a worker.

Read more...

Employer’s disciplinary process didn’t force resignation

I'll go first

The commencement of a disciplinary process against an employee is not an insignificant matter. It serves to notify an employee that their employer has serious concerns about their employment; whether that is the standard of the employee’s performance, their conduct or their behaviour.

Read more...

Salary reduction brought employee under high income threshold

Below not above

The COVID-19 (coronavirus) pandemic has significantly impacted the financial stability of many businesses. Employers have had to make difficult decisions and implement different measures to ensure the ongoing viability of their businesses. Some of these measures have included asking employees to agree to temporary reductions in their hours of work or to a reduction in their remuneration.

Read more...

Company vicariously liable for injury resulting from skylarking supervisor

All in good fun

Enjoying the company of your colleagues is something most people hope to find in the workplace. It can make work much more enjoyable and lead to lasting friendships. However, fun in the workplace can cross a line when it takes the form of dangerous skylarking or roughhousing.

Read more...

Managing employee conduct and behaviour in the workplace

Draw the line

Managing employee conduct and behaviour can be a challenge. The question of what is appropriate and what is not appropriate in the workplace will depend on a variety of factors, including the industry in which the employees work, the overall culture of the workplace and community standards at any given time.

Read more...

Let's talk

please contact our directors to discuss how ouR expertise can help your business.

We're here to help

Contact Us
Let Workplace Law become your partner in Workplace Relations.

Signup to receive the latest industry updates with commentary from the Workplace Law team direct to you inbox.